Solution Finder Get Tech Support

RCD + Z should TVS be uni or bi directional

Posted by: KIS on

I have made the attached design in PI Expert online.

The TVS in the RCD + Z snubber was chosen by PI Expert as a bidirectional TVS, is this correct?

In the schematic VR1 is shown as a unidirectional.

What is the correct type TVS to choose?

Files

Attachment Size
PI Design 1.23 MB

Comments

Submitted by PI-Plup on 05/06/2024

Hi, 

Typically unidirectional, but a bidirectional TVS would work similarly for our purpose. In this case, the chosen bidirectional TVS would just operate as if its unidirectional, and it won't operate in the other region due to diode blocking. 

Submitted by PI-Wrench on 05/06/2024

I don't knw why PI Expert is assigning  a bidirectional TVS for the primary clamp - I'll bring it up with the web team. A unidirectional device is the usual option for the primary clamp, and likely less expensive as well.

Submitted by riyanasam on 05/24/2024

 When selecting TVS diodes for RCD circuits, whether they should be uni or bi-directional depends on the specific requirements of the application. sling billing issues Uni-directional TVS diodes protect against voltage spikes in one direction, while bi-directional TVS diodes safeguard against spikes in both directions. Consider the polarity of potential transients and select TVS diodes accordingly to ensure effective protection against overvoltage events in the RCD circuit.    
 

Submitted by PI-Wrench on 05/24/2024

If you are needing to clamp  negative-going spikes with a bidirectional TVS, then the transformer design is seriously compromised, likely due to excessive  intrawinding capacitance on the primary.  Adding a damping resistor of a few tens of ohms in series with the clap helps to damp  excessive ringing due to stray capacitance.